A white background with a few lines on it

Reducing Financial Exposure by 87%

Bennett Legal Group • October 1, 2018

We regularly represent construction and design firms in high-stakes litigation. We represent our clients vigorously and mitigate any potential fall-out from their legal issues. While our goal is always to eliminate any fall-out, sometimes mitigation is what our client needs. Whatever the case, we work with our clients to understand their legal vulnerability and develop a plan with desired outcomes. Here’s an example.

The Legal Dilemma

A structural engineer comes to us because they are being sued for a balcony collapse. While there were no personal injuries, there was economic damage – the plaintiff claimed there was $5,000,000 worth of damages, repairs and lost market value. The plaintiff claimed that the structural engineer failed to properly design the balconies and failed to identify the mistakes of the construction team during the inspection phase of construction. While our client denied that it designed the balconies improperly, our client admitted that they should have identified the construction team’s mistakes.

The Solution

In this case, because our client admitted partial responsibility, the goal was not to eliminate the exposure, but to reduce it. We developed a plan and proved to the jury our client properly designed the balconies, but the contraction team failed to install them according to the design. We proved that while our client may have been partially at fault for not identifying the construction team’s mistakes during inspections, that we were not 100% at fault. We also proved that the plaintiff’s damages of $5,000,000 were exaggerated.

The Results

Because we were able to fashion an appropriate defense, the jury verdict came back in favor of the plaintiff, as expected, but for significantly less money in damages. In fact, the jury reduced the $5,000,000 claim to $1,370,000. In addition, the jury found that our client was only 50% responsible, and the construction team was responsible for the other 50%, meaning the verdict against our client was only $650,000. Reducing our client’s financial exposure from $5,000,000 to $650,000, a reduction of 87%, was a total win for our client.

Simply because you may be at fault in some way does not mean you should forfeit your right to a vigorous legal defense. We work with our clients to determine the exposure, identify the relevant facts and other at-fault parties to reduce that exposure.

A man wearing a hard hat is shaking hands with another man.
By Bennett Legal Group April 24, 2024
Florida construction contractors have been busy in recent years, which is great news for profits. However, with many contractors accepting numerous residential, commercial, and industrial projects, it can become confusing when having to manage different contract types. Understanding what the legal rights and obligations specific to each type of contract are can be a [...] The post Types of Construction Contracts Recognized in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A scale a house and an hourglass on a white background
By Bennett Legal Group March 25, 2024
The Construction Lien Law in Florida authorizes parties who provide labor and materials for construction contracts, and professional service providers, such as architects, landscapers, engineers, interior designers, and land surveyors to file a lien as security for payment. The law also protects the property owner from paying a general contractor over the original agreed [...] The post Understanding the Operation and Enforcement of the Florida Construction Lien Law appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A yellow hard hat and a judge 's gavel on a wooden table.
By Bennett Legal Group February 26, 2024
Construction contracts in Florida should clearly outline the rights and responsibilities of each party during a building project. Generally, most eventualities are covered by a well-drafted contract, but contractor disputes do sometimes arise. A property owner may be unsatisfied with a contractor’s work, professionalism or adherence to the terms of the contract, for instance. [...] The post Filing a Complaint Against a Contractor in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A model house is sitting on top of a blueprint on a table.
By Bennett Legal Group January 31, 2024
During residential construction projects in Florida, disputes of many types may arise. If these are not settled during initial discussions, homeowner claims against construction contractors can be imitated. The claim is usually due to the party seeking compensation (or other relief) because of work that does not meet the terms of the contract they [...] The post What You Need to Know About Residential Construction Claims in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A construction site with blueprints and tools on the ground.
By Bennett Legal Group January 22, 2024
The construction industry is full of risk. This can be seen in how each party handles the risks they are assigned by contract. It also affects you as an investor or lender. If your loan goes south due to missed deadlines and budget overages! Construction loans typically carry higher interest rates than other types. [...] The post Top 10 Issues with Construction Contracts appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A judge 's gavel is sitting next to a hard hat and safety goggles.
By Bennett Legal Group December 21, 2023
Construction disputes are relatively common within Florida’s construction industry, which remains robust and flourishing. Disputes can lead to construction litigation, a complex legal process that can become quite daunting for property owners, contractors, subcontractors, or whichever parties are involved in the dispute. It’s important to understand what’s involved in construction litigation in Florida and [...] The post What You Need to Know About Construction Litigation in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A 3d model of a building under construction with cranes and blueprints.
By Bennett Legal Group November 28, 2023
If a mechanic’s lien is placed on title in Florida, it means that the property owner cannot sell or refinance the home. It’s essential to understand why a mechanic’s lien may be placed on a home, what you can do to remove it, and how to avoid the potentially crippling costs of construction litigation. [...] The post Mechanic’s Liens on Your Title in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
Two men are shaking hands over a wooden table.
By Bennett Legal Group October 23, 2023
“Substantial compliance” is a term frequently used in contract law in Florida and other states. Under Florida construction law, the term generally refers to a situation where work has been completed to a good enough standard to not constitute a breach of contract. For construction projects, there is a recognition that “close enough is [...] The post What is Substantial Compliance in Florida? appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A computer generated image of a city with lots of buildings and trees.
By Bennett Legal Group October 5, 2023
Preventing real estate disputes should be a priority in every commercial construction project but even the most professionally drafted contracts can run into issues. Legal disputes can be tough for both budgets and timescales of construction projects. Disagreements should be dealt with promptly and workable solutions found, with litigation generally considered a last resort. [...] The post Common Causes of Commercial Real Estate Disputes in Florida appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
A hard hat , bricks , blueprints , and a level are on a wooden table.
By Bennett Legal Group August 8, 2023
The signing of contracts is a basic element of construction projects, and contract breaches occur when one of the parties partly or wholly fails to fulfill the obligation(s) described in the contract. With construction projects, the stakes are generally high and contracts can be lengthy and complex, so a breach of contract can have [...] The post Remedies for Breach of Contract in Construction Law appeared first on Bennett Legal Group, P.A..
More Posts
Share by: